Former FBI negotiator questions reported ransom note in Nancy Guthrie case

A former FBI hostage negotiator has raised doubts about a reported ransom note linked to the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, saying one detail is unusual for a genuine kidnapping for ransom.

Guthrie, the mother of Today co-host Savannah Guthrie, disappeared from her home in Tucson, Arizona, around 1 February. More than five months later, no arrests have been made and her whereabouts remain unknown.

Crime journalist Briana Whitney recently discussed two alleged ransom notes on the Crime Junkie podcast. The notes have not been independently verified.

According to Whitney, the first note demanded US$4 million in bitcoin by 5 February, warning the amount would rise to US$6 million if payment was delayed. It also stated there would be "no negotiation" and that the family would not be able to contact the sender.

Retired FBI hostage negotiator Jason Pack said that, if authentic, this is not typical of ransom cases.

He said kidnappers seeking money usually keep communication open so they can arrange payment. A message that cuts off contact suggests the writer may have been trying to create fear and control rather than collect a ransom.

Whitney also described a second alleged note claiming Guthrie had died soon after being taken, reportedly from a heart-related medical issue. Her family previously said she had health problems and did not have her medication when she disappeared.

Despite the lack of public updates, Pack said investigations can continue behind the scenes as long as detectives have leads to pursue. The case remains unsolved.